Mortgage Comparison UK: Fixed, Tracker and Discount Deals Explained With a Product-Checking Worksheet
mortgage comparisonfixed-rate mortgagestracker mortgagesremortgagingbuyer budgeting

Mortgage Comparison UK: Fixed, Tracker and Discount Deals Explained With a Product-Checking Worksheet

HHomebuying.uk Editorial Team
2026-11-20
6 min read

Compare UK fixed, tracker and discount mortgages with a practical worksheet covering rates, fees, risks, flexibility and affordability.

Comparing mortgages in the UK is about more than choosing the lowest advertised rate. This guide explains the differences between fixed, tracker and discount mortgages, shows which costs and restrictions to check, and provides a reusable worksheet for comparing products when you buy, remortgage or reach the end of an introductory period.

Overview

A mortgage comparison should answer one practical question: what is the likely cost and risk of each product over the period you expect to keep it?

The initial interest rate matters, but it is only one part of the decision. You should also check the lender’s follow-on rate, arrangement fee, valuation or legal incentives, early repayment charges, overpayment rules, portability, term length and eligibility assumptions. A product that looks cheapest on a comparison table may not be suitable if its fee is high, its restrictions do not fit your plans, or you may need to leave before the incentive period ends.

The three common product types are:

  • Fixed-rate mortgage: the interest rate is fixed for an agreed introductory period. Your mortgage payment for the rate-and-term portion should remain predictable, although other household costs can change.
  • Tracker mortgage: the rate normally moves in relation to a stated reference rate. Payments can rise or fall, so you need enough budget capacity for changes.
  • Discount mortgage: the lender offers a reduction from its variable rate for a set period. The payment may change if the underlying rate changes.

After an introductory period, a mortgage may move to the lender’s follow-on variable rate unless you choose a new product. Check the offer and mortgage illustration rather than assuming the initial rate will continue.

How to estimate the cost of a mortgage

Start with the same inputs for every product. Record the loan amount, repayment term, introductory rate, introductory period, product fee and any other compulsory cost. Then estimate the monthly payment using a reliable UK mortgage calculator. A repayment mortgage payment depends on the amount borrowed, interest rate and remaining term; an interest-only mortgage needs a separate assessment because the capital generally remains outstanding.

For a simple comparison, calculate:

  1. Initial payments: monthly payment multiplied by the number of months in the introductory period.
  2. Product costs: add arrangement or product fees and any known compulsory costs. If a fee is added to the mortgage, include the interest charged on that extra borrowing in a full comparison.
  3. Exit costs: include any early repayment charge, repayment administration fee or other cost that could apply if you leave during the introductory period.
  4. Post-introductory position: note the follow-on rate, but do not treat it as a guaranteed long-term rate. Your likely options may include switching to another product, subject to affordability, property value and lender criteria at the time.

A useful comparison is therefore not just “rate versus rate”. It is an estimate of the cost of staying for a defined period, alongside a clear record of what could change.

Mortgage product comparison worksheet

QuestionProduct AProduct B
Product typeFixed, tracker or discountFixed, tracker or discount
Loan amount and term£_____ / _____ years£_____ / _____ years
Initial rate_____ %_____ %
Introductory period_____ months_____ months
Estimated initial payment£_____ per month£_____ per month
Follow-on rate_____ % and how it is set: __________ % and how it is set: _____
Product or arrangement fee£_____£_____
Other costs or incentives__________
Early repayment charge__________
Overpayment allowance__________
PortabilityYes / no / conditions: _____Yes / no / conditions: _____
Eligibility assumptionsLoan-to-value, income and property: _____Loan-to-value, income and property: _____
Estimated cost during initial period£_____£_____

Inputs and assumptions to check

Loan-to-value (LTV): calculate the mortgage as a percentage of the property value. Your deposit and valuation affect this figure, and products may be available only within particular LTV bands. Do not assume that a small change in the property price will automatically qualify you for a different product.

Affordability: lenders assess income, regular commitments, household spending and other information. A mortgage calculator can estimate payments, but it cannot confirm how much you can borrow. For wider budgeting guidance, see How Much Can I Borrow for a Mortgage in the UK?

Fees and incentives: compare the total cost, not just the rate. A product fee may be paid upfront or added to the loan. Free valuation or legal incentives may have conditions, and a cashback payment may not offset a higher rate.

Rate risk: with a tracker or discount product, test a higher payment than the current estimate. With a fixed product, the immediate payment is more predictable, but you still need to consider what happens when the fixed period ends.

Flexibility: check whether you can overpay, make lump-sum payments, transfer the mortgage when moving, or repay it early without a charge. Portability is not always automatic: a new property and your circumstances may still need to meet the lender’s criteria.

Term: extending the term can reduce the monthly payment but may increase the total interest paid. If you compare different terms, record them clearly so that a lower monthly figure is not mistaken for a lower overall cost.

Read the mortgage illustration and offer documents carefully. If a broker recommends a product, ask which assumptions were used and whether the recommendation accounts for your expected time in the property.

Worked examples

These figures are illustrative only and are not current quotes. They assume a £200,000 repayment mortgage over 25 years, with no rate changes during the initial period and no added fee interest. Actual payments depend on the lender’s calculation method, dates, fees and eligibility.

Two-year fixedTwo-year tracker
Illustrative initial rate5.00%4.50%
Illustrative monthly paymentAbout £1,169About £1,111
Illustrative product fee£999£499
Payments over 24 months plus feeAbout £29,063About £27,163

On these assumptions, the tracker starts with the lower estimated cost. That does not make it automatically better: its rate can change, while the fixed product offers greater payment certainty during the fixed period. If the tracker rate rises, the difference may narrow or reverse. If either product is repaid early, an early repayment charge could materially alter the result.

For a meaningful decision, repeat the calculation using a higher tracker rate, include the relevant fees, and estimate how long you expect to keep the product. Then compare the payment with your household budget rather than relying on the maximum a lender may offer.

When to recalculate and what to do next

Revisit your mortgage comparison whenever pricing inputs or your circumstances change. Useful trigger points include:

  • before applying for an agreement in principle;
  • when your deposit, income, debts or regular spending changes;
  • when a fixed, tracker or discount period is approaching its end;
  • when you are considering an early remortgage or overpayment;
  • when the property value or your estimated LTV changes;
  • when a lender changes its fees, criteria or follow-on rate; and
  • when you are deciding whether to move home and need to assess portability.

Keep a dated copy of each comparison, including the rate, fee, term, LTV assumption and product conditions. Recheck the figures against the latest mortgage illustration before making an application. A mortgage broker or lender can explain eligibility and product details, while an independent adviser can help you assess whether the risks fit your circumstances.

Finally, compare affordability under more than one outcome: the payment you expect today, a higher payment if a variable rate rises, and the likely payment when a fixed period ends. This turns a mortgage comparison from a search for the lowest headline rate into a repeatable decision that can be updated as the market and your plans change.

Related Topics

#mortgage comparison#fixed-rate mortgages#tracker mortgages#remortgaging#buyer budgeting
H

Homebuying.uk Editorial Team

Property and mortgage editor

Senior editor and content strategist. Writing about technology, design, and the future of digital media. Follow along for deep dives into the industry's moving parts.